Chapter Fourteen of Helena, a novel in progress. This work of fiction examines Christian nationalism, political power, and the corruption of religious language.


The wall returned Helena to work.

She had not expected it. An adverse witness had lost her protection and the safeguards of the pending covenant review; she had assumed she would lose her station as well. Instead, on the second morning, the wall showed the old instruction, unchanged since before any of it began.

REPORT FOR ASSIGNED DUTY.

The employment center was exactly as she had left it, which was the strange part. The same rows. The same blue stations waking under the same tone. The station that had been Mara’s stood empty, its barrier lowered into the floor, the sealed notice still lit.

Helena placed her hands inside the marked area of her own station. The black compliance band stayed silent, and the dead white band beside it caught the light and gave nothing back.

GOOD MORNING, HELENA.

The greeting had not changed either. The system did not know how to be ashamed. It had reduced a woman to forty-nine percent, returned that woman’s friend to her desk, and wished the friend good morning, all in the same untroubled courtesy.

Across the room, Livia entered. She looked at Helena’s dark band, and then at Helena, and she did not slow her step. But she took the station nearest Helena’s, which was not her own, and no one corrected her.

Helena’s screen turned gold before the starting tone.

SPECIAL ASSIGNMENT

DISCREPANCY RESOLUTION

CASE MV-77241 · LINKED CANDIDATE REVIEW CI-204-1187

She understood the shape of it at once, because she had seen it before. They had assigned her Mara’s case in this room once, had called it error-correction support, and had watched to see what she would do. They were doing it again. They held a discrepancy they could not resolve, and they had handed it to the witness who had made it, in the hope that she would take it back.

Two columns opened.

The left was her own statement, HV-11608. I found no medical record confirming pregnancy. I found four medical records stating that the subject was not pregnant.

The right was the authorized finding. Incomplete medical sequence. Memory fragmentation.

Between them, for the first time, a third column.

It was headed CORROBORATION, and it was not empty.

SOURCE RECORDS PRESERVED BY CI-204-1187.

Beneath the heading sat the four medical examinations, the originals, the ones Nathan had refused four times to let disappear. They stood in the record now not as history but as evidence, and they said what they had always said.

REPRODUCTIVE STATUS: NOT PREGNANT.

A prompt appeared.

SELECT CORRECTION.

Helena moved the cursor to the authorized finding. If she could mark it as the error, if she could make the system call the lie a lie, then the truth would stand uncorrected and Mara’s denial would be what it was.

She selected it.

CORRECTION REQUIRES RESOLUTION OF CORROBORATING WITNESS CI-204-1187.

She moved to her own statement instead. She did not wish to correct it. She wished to see.

She selected it.

CORRECTION REQUIRES RESOLUTION OF CORROBORATING SOURCE RECORDS. RECORDS PRESERVED BY CI-204-1187.

She selected the source records.

CORRECTION REQUIRES RESOLUTION OF CORROBORATING WITNESS HV-11608.

She sat back.

Her testimony could not be corrected without first correcting Nathan’s records. Nathan’s records could not be corrected without first correcting her testimony. The authorized finding could not be laid over either through this correction process while the other stood. Each statement required the examiner to account for the other. The screen offered no operation that could close both together.

She had spent years correcting single things. A date. A name. A denial that stood alone and could be replaced with a confession because nothing stood beside it to object. She had never been asked to correct two things that held each other up.

She heard Livia’s voice from the far side of a lunch table, turning a water packet so the printed verse faced her.

In the mouth of two or three witnesses shall every word be established.

One witness can be corrected. Two create a discrepancy.

Helena had taken it for caution at the time — that two witnesses were harder to silence than one. She saw now that it was more exact than caution. It was a property of the machine. The system corrected by setting one source against a stronger source and keeping the stronger. This review had no permitted correction for two independent sources of equal weight that pointed at the same truth and refused to disagree. Correction needed a discrepancy it could resolve. She and Nathan were a discrepancy it could not.

At the bottom of the screen, the linked review reported itself.

INDIVIDUAL REVIEW: CI-204-1187 — SUSPENDED.

CORRECTION UNAVAILABLE. CORROBORATION INTACT.

For a moment something in Helena’s chest lifted. They had put Nathan in the room, and the room could not do to him what it had done to Mara, because everything they might use to reduce him was confirmed by what she had said, and everything they might use to reduce her was confirmed by what he had kept. As long as both records stood, neither could be made an error through this review without leaving the other unanswered.

Then Livia spoke, without turning her head, in the flat voice people used when they did not want a band to register the shape of speech.

“You are pleased,” she said. “Don’t be.”

“They can’t correct him,” Helena said, as quietly.

“No.”

“Then he is safe.”

“He is the opposite of safe.” Livia moved a case from one side of her screen to the other, so that anyone watching would see two auditors at work. “You have made a thing the system cannot fix. It has one answer for a thing it cannot fix.”

Helena waited.

“I have seen this sequence before,” Livia said. “It cannot make two witnesses accept its finding. So it will make them one.”

The words settled slowly.

“Correction resolves a discrepancy by changing a record,” Livia said. “When the records will not change, the discrepancy is resolved another way. You do not correct two witnesses. You remove one. Then the survivor is a single source again, and a single source can be corrected into anything at all.”

Helena looked at the sealed station that had been Mara’s.

Helena saw what medical custody had made possible. Whether or not anyone had named the purpose aloud, it had removed Mara by degrees — a witness reduced, point by point, until she could corroborate no one, until sixty-seven became forty-nine and forty-nine became a number too low to establish anything. Mara had not been silenced. She had been subtracted, slowly, so that two witnesses who might have held each other up would become one, and the one could be corrected, and the correction would be called a reconciliation.

They had not finished with Mara. And now there were two more.

The state had written the standard into its own law. Two independent witnesses required for capital classification — she had read it at her workstation while the government used her audit to condemn Mara. Now two independent sources obstructed the correction of that same record. For a moment she had mistaken the obstruction for immunity. Livia was telling her that the rule governed what an examiner could close on a screen. It did not govern every order another office might issue against a body.

“So what happens,” Helena said.

Livia closed her case and opened another.

“They will decide which of you is easier to remove,” she said. “Then they will begin.”

Helena’s screen cleared. The discrepancy resolution closed itself, unresolved, the way it would stay unresolved for as long as both of them held. In its place the ordinary queue returned — address corrections, attendance reports, the small daily editing of a country’s memory.

She placed her hands in the marked area and did not begin.

Across the room stood the sealed station of a woman still being subtracted. Somewhere Helena could not see, a door had opened for Nathan onto a review that could not yet close his testimony. And between the two of them, invisible and stable and wholly beyond her power to guard, stood the thing she and Nathan had become without choosing it: two witnesses, established, and marked for exactly that reason.


Previous: Individual Review — Chapter Thirteen

Copyright © 2026 Steven Davis. All rights reserved.